Dragon Puzzle!

DragonManJ13's picture

4 guys played in a chess tournament. Based on their statements, answer the two questions.

Note: only one of them is lying. The other three are telling the truth.

Man #1: I was not able to win.

Man #2: I lost to Man #4, but i beat Man #3.

Man #3: I didn't finish last, by the way.

Man #4: Only Man #3 and Man #2 lost to me.

1. Which one of them is lying?

2. In what order did they place?

Note: yes, i realize this has nothing to do with Dragons.

Leela's picture

Hmm...

I don't know how a chess tournament works. And because Foppy is secretly evil, he won't tell me. (Since he knows.) >:-( Grrr...

*Whatever. I just won't participate. ;) *

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

Savage Karioke. Find your inner self.

Dragon Karioke. Don't ask.

♥♫♪◉☼

The funeral was boring till the Irish dancers came in.

Fopsworth's picture

Answer

Man#4 is lying. Why? We don't know. He actually beat everyone else in the tournament.

1st. Man#4

2nd. Man#2

3rd. Man#3

4th. Man#1

Gregory's Dance Studio - Teaches everything from tap to the grim fandango!

"Sir, the ketchup is becoming violently familiar with the guests." - me

Aisling's picture

Ooh. Logic problems!

Hmm, now. Let's see.

Due to logical dependencies, Man #4 must be the liar.

So then the placing would be something like:

Man #1 - last place

Man #2 - second place

Man #3 - third place

Man #4 - first place

But, that's based on the assumpition that Man #2 beat #1 instead of not playing him. So, actually it's just a guess... :D

---------------

"If they'd use more than their eyes,

They'd be able to see,

The heavenly beauty,

Inside of me."

-Echoing Green's Supermodel Citizen

You know how to raspberry, don't you Steve? You just put your tongue out and blow.

Quartz's picture

Yes

I was actually going to ask, “Would #4 necessarily have had to play #1 at all, or is it possible that #1 got eliminated entirely by #2 and #3 before #4 had a chance at him?” Because if the latter was true, then #4 wasn’t necessarily lying.

-------

“The Stone the builders rejected has become the Cornerstone. This is the Lord’s doing, and it is marvellous in our eyes.” –Psalm 118:22-23

“[Jesus said,] ‘Heaven and earth will pass away, but my words will not pass away.’” –Matthew 24:35 (ESV)

SangMing's picture

Looks like this was fun.

I appreciate the ways you entertain us, Dragon. I'm sorry I can't participate in most of these games. This one would have been a lot of fun for me.

---------------

I get up, I walk, I fall down. Meanwhile, I keep dancing. - Hillel

---------------

I get up, I walk, I fall down. Meanwhile, I keep dancing. - Hillel